Is Your Pool Leaking or Just Evaporating? The Bucket Test and Other Signs
By September, a lot of Atlanta pool owners notice the same thing. The water line keeps dropping, the auto-fill seems to run nonstop, and the water bill looks a little high. The big question: is the pool leaking, or is the late-summer heat simply evaporating the water away?
Both are common, and they can look almost identical at first. This guide shows you how to tell if your pool is leaking, how to do the simple bucket test, and what signs mean it's time to call a professional.
How Much Evaporation Is Normal?
Every outdoor pool loses water to evaporation. How much depends on heat, sun, humidity, and wind. During hot, sunny, breezy stretches, a pool can lose around a quarter inch a day, sometimes more. Over a week, that can add up to an inch or two.
What Speeds Up Evaporation
- Hot air and warm water, especially in a heated pool
- Low humidity and steady wind
- Waterfalls, fountains, and spillovers that spray water into the air
- Heavy splashing from a busy pool day
So a pool that drops a bit after a hot, windy week isn't automatically leaking. The key is comparing your loss to what evaporation alone would explain.
How to Tell If Your Pool Is Leaking: The Bucket Test
The bucket test is the easiest way to separate evaporation from a leak. It works because water in a bucket evaporates at roughly the same rate as the pool beside it.
Step by Step
- Turn off any auto-fill valve.
- Fill a bucket with pool water to about an inch from the top.
- Set the bucket on the first or second pool step so it sits in the pool water.
- Mark the water level inside the bucket and the pool's water level on the outside of the bucket.
- Run the pump on its normal schedule for 24 hours.
- Compare the two drops.
Reading the Results
If both levels dropped about the same amount, you're looking at evaporation. If the pool dropped noticeably more than the bucket, you likely have a leak.
Narrow It Down
Repeat the test with the pump off for 24 hours. If the pool loses more water with the pump running, the leak may be on the pressure side of the plumbing. If it loses more with the pump off, look at the suction side or the shell itself.
Weekend Test Tip: Don't run the bucket test during a rainstorm or a pool party. Rain and splashing throw off the results. Pick a calm 24-hour window, keep everyone out, and write down your measurements so you can share them with a technician.
Other Signs of a Pool Leak
The bucket test is the best check, but these clues often show up too.
- Wet or soggy spots in the yard near the pool or along the plumbing route
- Water around the equipment pad or drips from the pump, filter, or heater
- Air bubbles in the pump basket or return jets, which can point to a suction leak
- Cracks in the plaster, tile, or deck
- Loose or falling tiles at the waterline
- Constant chemical imbalance or algae, since fresh fill water keeps diluting your chemistry
- A higher water bill without another explanation
Picture a family in Dunwoody who adds a hose's worth of water every few days all summer and chalks it up to the heat. By September, the yard near the deep end stays soft even on dry days. That soggy patch is the clue. Water that isn't going into the air is going into the ground.
Common Places Pools Leak
Equipment and Plumbing
Pump seals, filter O-rings, valves, and fittings are frequent culprits. These leaks are often easy to see and relatively simple to fix. A dripping pump can also be a sign the seal is wearing out, which we cover in our post on how long pool pumps last.
Skimmers and Returns
The joint where a skimmer meets the pool shell can crack or separate over time, especially after freeze-thaw cycles.
Lights and Fittings
Pool lights, return fittings, and main drains all pass through the shell and can leak around their seals.
The Shell Itself
Cracks in plaster or concrete are less common but more serious. Georgia's shifting clay soil can stress a pool shell over time.
Worth Knowing: A slow leak rarely stays slow. Water escaping into the soil can wash out the ground under your deck or plumbing, and a small repair today can turn into a much larger one next year.
When to Call a Professional
If the bucket test points to a leak, or you see any of the signs above, it's time for a professional inspection. Finding the exact source often takes specialized tools and experience.
Pinnacle Pools has served metro Atlanta homeowners for years with weekly service and repairs, and their technicians can check equipment, plumbing, and fittings to narrow down where water is going. Learn more about their Atlanta pool repair services, or review the signs your pool needs a professional repair.
Don't Let Your Savings Drain Away
Some water loss is normal, especially after a hot Georgia summer. The bucket test tells you whether it's evaporation or a leak in just 24 hours. If the pool is losing more than the bucket, or you're seeing soggy spots and drips, call Pinnacle Pools at 770-945-6360 before a small leak becomes a big repair.
FAQs
What's the best way to tell if a pool is leaking without a professional?
The best way to tell if a pool is leaking on your own is the bucket test. Set a bucket of pool water on the steps, mark both water levels, and compare after 24 hours. If the pool drops more than the bucket, there's likely a leak. Repeat with the pump off to narrow down where it is.
Does homeowners insurance cover pool leaks?
It depends on your policy. Some policies cover sudden, accidental damage to the pool structure or plumbing, while slow leaks and wear and tear are often excluded. Check your policy and call your insurer before repairs if you think a claim might apply. Documenting the bucket test results can help.




